Savings Blog

Watch out for costly ATMs that charge more than flat fees
by Jen A. Miller
February 3, 2012
In some places, your ATM fee is tied to a percentage of how much you withdraw, which could cost you well more than today

I recently saw a tweet by Peter Eavis, a reporter with the New York Times, about the ATM fee he encountered.

To use the ATM at a Holiday Inn in Florida, he was required to pay a surcharge of either $3 or 3% of the transaction, whichever was higher (and, of course, not including the fee his bank would charge him for using an out-of-network ATM).

The ATM fee for his withdrawal: $6.60.

Doing the math, that was a $220 withdrawal that cost 2 1/2 times the national average ATM fee to complete.

Felix Salmon of Reuters saw the tweet, too, and wrote that this practice is common in strip clubs. (Sorry, no firsthand experience there, though some of my Twitter followers said they've seen $10 ATM fees at strip clubs.)

I'd never heard of this percentage practice before, so I asked two experts -- Kathleen Day of the Center for Responsible Lending, a consumer advocacy group, and Will Weidman, who analyzes banking practices for Arlington, Va.-based Applied Predictive Technologies. This practice was news to them, too.

Could this spread?

Perhaps, though Weidman pointed out that few banks have actually implemented steep ATM surcharges as promised because of public backlash (a la Chase's $5 ATM fee, which never made it off the ground).

Either way, you need to really be careful and read what an ATM screen is telling you, especially independent ATMs like the ones you'll see in bars, convenience stores and bodegas because they almost always charge higher fees.

It might be worth the walk to a brick-and-mortar bank.

The adult entertainment industry is known to be an early adopter (i.e., the Internet). We're hoping it's not the case with percentage ATM surcharges.

I mentioned earlier I asked for stories of high ATM fees on Twitter, and I was told about $15 fees in Las Vegas casinos and a $10 ATM fee at Renaissance fairs.

What's the highest surcharge you've seen?

You can follow Interest.com on Twitter and Facebook.

February 06, 2012 - 6:24 pm - by Amy Fontinelle
By using an online bank that reimburses ATM fees, consumers can use any ATM they want and ignore the fees.
February 03, 2012 - 12:04 pm - by Ellie
There's a wacky story on CNNMoney about the growing number of states looking into issuing their own currencies. Utah -- who knew -- has already done this by allowing U.S.-minted gold and silver coins to be used as a form of payment. They are exchanged at market value, not face value.
February 03, 2012 - 11:07 am - by bethany
Surprisingly good jobs news today. The Labor Department says employers added 243,000 jobs in January -- which topped December's 203,000. And the unemployment rate fell to 8.3%. The Dow likes it!
VIEW ALL